Post by Jonathan L. Davis

This piece about a girl who went online and dated a nerd has already gone viral and it’s already gotten tons of attention. And it’s definitely in that aggravating category of Internet posting where an extremely flawed piece is so popular that the author will likely write off legitimate criticism as “controversy.” It’s the reality show contestant approach to popularity.
If the Internet is still the Internet, then my bet is she will write a follow up article and she will quote the most unhinged responses. And then her defense will be as follows:
1) “Nerds are IN right now. Nerds rule the world. So I’m the one being counterculture!”
There are silicon valley computer and programming inventors who are powerful and wealthy. They are IN. Because they are powerful and wealthy. Regular workaday silicon valley employees are NOT IN.
There are also good looking people who occasionally wear glasses and have some familiarity with Star Wars and X-Men and the big name comic writers. They are called geek-chic. They are IN. For the moment. The rest of the nerd community are the people who do the real work, watching Torchwood: Miracle Day, bagging and boarding comics from the New Universe line, playing Magic: The Gathering and wondering if their software is compatible with Apple Lion. They are NOT IN. They are not geek-chic. If you think you’re being contrarian by making fun of real nerds, you’re STILL a cliche. Sorry.
2) “People are allowed to have preferences.”
I agree with this. If you don’t like nerds, you don’t have to like nerds. If you like a guy with Umbros, like that guy with Umbros. If you don’t like that awkward guy with the Strikeforce: Morituri t-shirt on, you don’t have to like him. No one’s forcing you to like him. But it’s one thing to tell a guy quietly by the school locker that you aren’t interested and whole other thing to make fun of him in front of the school auditorium. It was not nice to name the harmless guy you went on an anonymous Internet date with. It’s not charming. It’s not a Carrie Bradshaw “wow, I really do like traditional guys after all; isn’t THAT interesting” moment. That’s a “wow, I’m the two-dimensional extra from Gossip Girl” moment.
3) “I was being mean. So what?”
Because you didn’t know WHY it was mean. It was mean without any real insight other than stuff we’ve already known about dating on the Internet since 2001. People are shallow. Call the paper. There are human beings on the other end of those search parameters. Usually.
And now for an aside. One last thing to say about Internet dating in general. I’ve dated online; I don’t think there’s anything wrong with it. And if you do it right, it’s a great opportunity to meet someone you wouldn’t normally meet. So yes, it’s been said before, sure, and I’m married and out of this game so it’s pretty easy to say again, but here’s my advice for Internet daters who don’t want to be single in perpetuity:

It’s not a deli. You can’t order people the way you want them. If you do it that way, you’ll get a sandwich that only looks like the sandwich you ordered. When you get home, that turkey will taste a lot like pastrami and there’s a whole bunch of extra mayonnaise you didn’t ask for. They’ll fuck you in the drive-through. And in the immortal words of Joe Pesci, they ALWAYS fuck you in the drive-through.